Thanksgiving Preorders are live. Pre-order yours now! Order by Nov. 20 · Pickup Nov. 22–27 Pre-Order Now
Jericho Cider Mill
Made at the mill

The Menu

Cider pressed right here, donuts fried all day, and pies baked from the family recipe. Looking for coffee? See the Cafe menu.

Gallon of Jericho Cider Mill apple cider on a red gingham cloth with green apples

Apple Cider

About 20 pounds of New York apples in every gallon. No preservatives, so keep it cold, or freeze it for later.

Half gallon$6.25
Gallon$11.75
Hot cider with cinnamon stick$4.00
Frozen apple cider$4.00-$5.00
Sugar-coated apple cider donut on a Jericho Cider Mill coffee cup

Cider Donuts

Made with our own cider and rolled in cinnamon sugar, fresh all day.

Single$2.50
5 Pack$10.00
Nuggets$5.00

Homemade Pies

Baked the same way since 1968, in the same kitchen where the first five pies sold out on day one.

Call 516-433-3360 to check today's pies.

Pre-Order for Thanksgiving

Order by Nov. 20 · Pickup Nov. 22–27

Golden homemade pies fresh from the oven
10 inch$29.50
6 inch$15.00
  • Apple Pie
  • Apple Crumb
  • Apple Pie, Low Sugar Special order
  • Apple Blueberry Crumb
  • Apple Raspberry Crumb
  • Apple Cranberry
  • Apple Peach Crumb
  • Cherry
  • Blueberry
  • Peach
  • Pumpkin
  • Pecan
  • Coconut Custard

Special order pies need to be ordered ahead. Call 516-433-3360 to place your order.

And more on the shelves

Candy ApplesMade in our kitchen.
Ice CreamApple Crumb
Vanilla
Chocolate
Cookies & Cream
Monster Cookie
and more
Baked GoodsJust Fruit Gluten free & vegan
Apple Crisp
Breads
Cookies
Jams & JelliesApple Butter
Fruit Jams
Fruit Preserves
Salsas
Salad Dressings
Vanilla Peaches

Pair it with a latte or dirty soda

See the Cafe